OEM vs Aftermarket Door Bin for LG & Kenmore Refrigerators: Honest Comparison (AAP73252202)

You're staring at a cracked door bin in your LG French door fridge, and the LG parts website just quoted you $140 for a genuine replacement. Meanwhile, you've found aftermarket options for $65.99. That's a $75 difference for what looks like the exact same piece of molded plastic.

Let's cut through the marketing and look at what you're actually getting.

Quick Answer

For door bins, aftermarket wins on value. The OEM part from LG costs 2x more, ships slower, and you're paying a premium for a logo that sits inside your fridge. Unless you're restoring a show-piece appliance or need it for a warranty claim, the aftermarket AAP73252202 delivers identical function at half the cost.

Side-by-Side Comparison

When OEM Makes Sense

There are exactly three scenarios where paying double for the LG-branded bin is worth considering:

You're under manufacturer warranty. If your fridge is still covered and LG is replacing parts for free, obviously take the OEM part. Don't pay out-of-pocket when the manufacturer owes you.

You're flipping the appliance for resale. Buyers doing pre-purchase inspections sometimes check part numbers. If you're selling a high-end LFX33975ST or LMXS30746S and want to command top dollar, the OEM sticker might matter. For personal use? Forget it.

You've had multiple aftermarket failures. This is rare with door bins (they're simple molded plastic with no moving parts), but if you've somehow burned through two aftermarket bins, bite the bullet and go OEM. At that point, you've spent the OEM price anyway.

When Aftermarket Wins

For 95% of repairs, the aftermarket AAP73252202 is the smarter choice. Here's why:

It's the same physical part. Door bins don't have electronics, motors, or precision tolerances. They're injection-molded ABS plastic with wire supports. The factories producing aftermarket bins often supply OEM manufacturers too — they just skip the LG branding step and pass the savings to you.

Better warranty coverage. Heima backs this bin with a full year warranty versus LG's standard 90 days. That tells you something about confidence in the product.

You actually get it this week. LG authorized parts dealers frequently backorder door bins for 10–14 days, especially for popular models like the LFXC24726S or LFXS32726S. Aftermarket ships immediately.

Compatible across 40+ models. This bin replaces AAP73252201, AAP73252211, and AP5602939 — fitting everything from older LFX series to newer LMXC23746D models. One part, massive compatibility.

Our Verdict

Save your money. The aftermarket AAP73252202 door bin delivers identical performance to the OEM part at $65.99 versus $130+. It fits perfectly, lasts just as long, and ships faster. Unless LG is paying for the repair under warranty, there's no rational reason to spend double for a logo no one will ever see.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will the aftermarket bin fit as tightly as the original?

Yes. The AAP73252202 is manufactured to OEM specifications with identical mounting points and dimensions. It clicks into the door liner slots on your LG or Kenmore fridge exactly like the factory part. If you're working with models like the LFX31935ST or LFCS31626S, the fit is precise.

Does using an aftermarket part void my refrigerator warranty?

No. The Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act protects your right to use aftermarket parts. LG can't void your compressor or sealed system warranty just because you installed a non-OEM door bin. That said, if the aftermarket part directly causes damage (extremely unlikely with a plastic bin), that specific damage might not be covered. Keep your receipt.

How do I know if this bin fits my specific LG model?

Check the model number on the sticker inside your fridge (usually on the left wall near the top). This AAP73252202 bin fits 40+ models including LFX25991ST, LFX31925ST/SB/SW, LFX31935ST, LFX33975ST, LFXC24726S, LFXS30726S/B/W, LFXS32726S, LMXC23746D, LMXS30746S, LFCS31626S, and many Kenmore 795 series. If your model starts with LFX or LFXS and was made between 2010–2020, you're almost certainly good.