Comparison

OEM vs Aftermarket Dryer Door Switch for Whirlpool: Honest Comparison (3406105)

4 min read
May 25, 2026
OEM Whirlpool price
$45–$65
Heima Aftermarket price
$21.99
Side-by-side comparison
3406105 3406105 Dryer Door Switch Assembly Compatible with Whirlpool Kenmore Maytag Roper, Replaces WP3406105 3406104 AP6008560 PS11741700

Your Whirlpool dryer won't start. You press the button, hear nothing, and the drum sits motionless. The door's closed properly, but the dryer thinks it's wide open. The culprit? That little door switch assembly — part number 3406105. Now you're staring at two options: the OEM Whirlpool version at $45–$65, or an aftermarket replacement at $21.99. Here's what you actually need to know.

Quick Answer

For a simple door switch that just completes a circuit, the aftermarket 3406105 is the smarter buy. You'll save $25–$45, get the same 15-minute install, and the part does exactly what the original did. Unless you're restoring a vintage dryer or your insurance requires OEM documentation, there's no functional advantage to paying double.

Side-by-Side Comparison

FactorOEM WhirlpoolHeima Aftermarket
Price$45–$65$21.99
Warranty90 days (dealer varies)1 year
Lead Time3–7 days (dealer order)Ships same/next day
Fit & FinishWhirlpool brandingUnbranded, identical function
Where MadeVaries (often same factories)ISO-certified facilities
InstallationLess than 15 minsLess than 15 mins

When OEM Makes Sense

There are legitimate scenarios where the OEM switch is worth the premium. If your dryer's still under manufacturer warranty, installing an aftermarket part might void coverage on related components — though the Magnuson-Moss Act technically protects you, fighting that battle isn't fun. If you're a landlord with commercial dryers in a rental property, some insurance policies specifically require OEM parts for liability claims. And if you're one of those people who keeps appliances for 25 years and wants every component branded, go for it.

The OEM switch also comes in Whirlpool packaging, which matters if you're reselling the dryer or maintaining property records. But functionally? It's the same two-wire switch closing the same circuit.

When Aftermarket Wins

For 95% of repairs, the aftermarket 3406105 is the obvious choice. The switch itself is dead simple — it's a mechanical lever that completes an electrical connection when the door closes. There's no circuit board, no calibration, no "genuine Whirlpool engineering." One customer put it perfectly: "Got what I needed and fixed my dryer." That's the entire point.

The price difference is significant. At $21.99 vs $45–$65, you're saving enough to buy a pack of dryer belts or a few vent clamps. And the warranty's actually better — one full year instead of 90 days. Installation's identical: two screws, two wire connectors, less than 15 minutes with a basic screwdriver. Another user noted, "Always great replacement parts. Loved you sharing the video." The install process doesn't change based on who manufactured the switch.

Shipping time matters when your dryer's been dead for three days and laundry's piling up. The aftermarket version ships same or next day. The OEM part usually requires a dealer order with 3–7 day wait times.

The Compatibility Reality

This switch works across Whirlpool, Kenmore, Maytag, and Roper dryers — models like LER4634PQ0, LER3622HQ0, CEDX463RQ0, and dozens more. The part replaces WP3406105, 3406104, AP6008560, and PS11741700. Whether you buy OEM or aftermarket, you're getting the same cross-compatibility because the mounting holes, wire terminals, and lever position are standardized.

Our Verdict

Buy the aftermarket 3406105 unless you have a specific warranty or insurance requirement. You'll save $25–$45, get a longer warranty, and receive it faster. The switch performs identically — it's a simple mechanical contact, not a precision component. Spend the savings on proper dryer vent cleaning, which actually prevents future problems.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will an aftermarket door switch last as long as OEM?

Yes. The switch is a basic mechanical component with a metal lever and contact points. Failure rates between OEM and quality aftermarket versions are virtually identical — both typically last 8–12 years under normal use. The longer warranty on aftermarket parts (1 year vs 90 days) suggests manufacturers stand behind durability.

Can I install this myself or do I need a technician?

This is one of the easiest dryer repairs. Unplug the dryer, remove two screws from the old switch, disconnect two wire terminals, reverse the process with the new switch. Takes less than 15 minutes with a basic screwdriver. No special tools, no disassembly of the drum or cabinet. If you can change a light fixture, you can replace this switch.

What if the aftermarket switch doesn't fix my "won't start" problem?

If your dryer still won't start after replacing the door switch, check the thermal fuse (also common) and the start switch. But door switch failure is the most common cause when the dryer won't start with the door closed. The symptom's distinctive — you can usually hear the switch not clicking when you close the door. With a 1-year warranty, you're covered if the part itself is defective, though that's rare.

Ready to go aftermarket?

3406105 · Factory direct · 1-year warranty

Shop 3406105 →