OEM vs Aftermarket 240351601 Freezer Door Bin: Which One Actually Fits Right?

You're standing in your kitchen looking at your Frigidaire side-by-side freezer with empty door slots where bins used to be. Maybe you just bought the house and the previous owners took them. Maybe one cracked after years of slamming. Either way, you need replacements — and you've found the OEM version on some parts site for $65, while our aftermarket 240351601 is $30.99. That's a $34 difference. So what are you actually giving up?

Quick Answer

For a freezer door bin, the aftermarket version from Heima delivers identical fit and function at less than half the OEM price. Unless you're selling the house tomorrow and need that Frigidaire logo for staging photos, save your money. Real users confirm: "Perfect fit" and "Replacing broken door parts is a breeze."

Side-by-Side Comparison

When OEM Makes Sense

Let's be honest: there aren't many scenarios where spending double makes sense for a plastic door bin. But here are two:

You're flipping the house. If you're staging for sale and buyers will inspect every detail, that little Frigidaire logo might matter. It's silly, but home inspectors notice these things.

You're replacing under warranty. If your fridge is still under manufacturer warranty and you're claiming the bin as part of a bigger repair, stick with OEM to avoid any pushback from the service tech.

That's it. For normal homeowners just trying to keep groceries organized, OEM is overkill.

When Aftermarket Wins

Here's where the aftermarket 240351601 makes perfect sense — which is basically every other situation:

Your fridge is out of warranty. Once that factory warranty expires (usually 1 year), there's zero reason to pay the OEM premium. You're getting the same polycarbonate plastic, same mounting clips, same everything.

You need multiple bins. One user reached out asking about door bins for their newly purchased house — the previous owner had cleaned out every single bin. Between the right door, left freezer door, and various sizes, you're looking at 6+ bins. At OEM prices that's $360+. With aftermarket? Under $200 for the whole set.

The bin broke from normal use. These bins crack from temperature cycling and door slamming — it's not your fault. One customer said it plainly: "Thank you again! Replacing broken door parts is a breeze." Why pay double to replace something that failed through normal wear?

"Perfect fit. Great service. Fits as should." — Verified purchaser who replaced bins on a FRS26H5ASB5

The aftermarket version ships faster, costs half as much, and has a longer warranty. It's manufactured to the exact same dimensional specs — often in the same overseas factories that supply the OEM brands.

Our Verdict

Save your money and go aftermarket. This isn't a compressor or control board where OEM engineering matters. It's an injection-molded bin that clips onto door tracks. Heima's version fits models from FRS26H5ASB5 to PLHS67E perfectly, ships same-day, and costs $30.99 vs $65+ for OEM. Unless you're staging for resale, there's no reason to overpay.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will the aftermarket 240351601 fit my specific Frigidaire model?

Yes, if your model is FRS26 series, FFHS series, GLHS series, or PLHS series (most Frigidaire side-by-sides from 2005–2020). This part replaces AP2115974, 240351607, and PS430027. Check your existing bin or your fridge manual for confirmation, but fitment is identical to OEM.

Is the plastic quality the same as OEM?

Yes. Both use high-impact polycarbonate plastic rated for freezer temperatures (-20°F to 40°F). The aftermarket version uses the same material spec — it has to, or it would crack within weeks. Real users report "perfect fit" with no issues after installation.

How long does the aftermarket bin actually last?

Expect 5–8 years of normal use, which is exactly what the OEM bins deliver. These fail from thermal stress and repeated impacts, not manufacturing quality. Whether you pay $30 or $65, you're getting roughly the same lifespan. The difference is you'll have $34 left over for groceries to fill that bin.