Comparison

OEM vs Aftermarket 3977767 High Limit Thermostat for Whirlpool/Kenmore: Honest Price Breakdown

4 min read
May 22, 2026
OEM Whirlpool price
$35–$50
Heima Aftermarket price
$10.99
Side-by-side comparison
3977767 3977767 Dryer High Limit Thermostat Compatible with Whirlpool Kenmore Maytag Roper, Replaces WP3977767 AP6009043 3399693 PS11742185

You're standing in your laundry room, frustrated. Your Whirlpool or Kenmore dryer runs but won't heat—you've tested the heating element and it's fine. The culprit? That little high limit thermostat (part 3977767). Now you're on the phone with the appliance parts store, and they're quoting you $45 for the OEM version. You check online and find aftermarket options for $10.99. What's the catch?

Let's cut through the sales pitch and look at what you're actually getting with each option.

Quick Answer

For this specific part, aftermarket is the smarter buy for 90% of DIYers. The OEM thermostat from Whirlpool costs 3-4x more, offers the same 1-year warranty most aftermarket suppliers provide, and performs identically in real-world conditions. Unless you're doing a warranty repair where OEM is required, save your money.

Side-by-Side Comparison

FactorOEM Whirlpool (WP3977767)Heima Aftermarket (3977767)
Price$35–$50$10.99
Warranty1 year (Whirlpool)1 year (Heima)
Lead Time3–7 days (dealer order)2–3 days (ships direct)
Fit & FinishWhirlpool packaging, exact OEM mountGeneric packaging, identical mount specs
ManufacturingContract manufacturer (often same factory)ISO-certified third party
Temperature Rating250°F cutoff250°F cutoff (same spec)

When OEM Makes Sense

There are exactly three scenarios where paying 4x the price for OEM is justified:

Your dryer is still under manufacturer warranty. If you've got 6 months left on your Whirlpool warranty, using an aftermarket part voids coverage on related components. Pay the premium and keep your warranty intact.

You're a landlord with commercial dryer service contracts. Some service agreements specifically require OEM parts for billing purposes. Check your contract language before ordering.

You've already failed with two aftermarket thermostats. It's rare, but if you've installed two different aftermarket high limit thermostats and both failed within weeks, there might be an underlying electrical issue causing premature failure. In that case, the OEM part won't fix your problem either—but at least you'll know for certain the thermostat isn't defective.

That's it. Those are the only legitimate reasons to spend $45 instead of $11.

When Aftermarket Wins

For the vast majority of home repairs, aftermarket is the obvious choice. Here's why:

It's the same component with a different label. High limit thermostats are dead-simple devices—a bimetallic disc that opens at 250°F. There's no proprietary Whirlpool magic here. Aftermarket manufacturers produce these to the exact same L250 temperature specification.

You'll finish the repair faster. OEM parts from Whirlpool often require ordering through an authorized dealer, which adds 3–5 days to your timeline. Aftermarket suppliers ship directly, usually arriving in 2–3 days. Your family wants clean clothes now, not next week.

The warranty is identical. Both OEM and quality aftermarket thermostats come with a 1-year warranty. If it fails, you're covered either way. The difference? You'll have $35 left in your pocket.

"Replaced the heating element and fuse. Had continuity through circuit but still wouldn't work. Replaced additional thermostats etc., it turns out that when the heating element shorted it also damaged the breaker, so I lost one leg of the circuit. Hence the drum would turn but no heat. Check the breaker for 240." — Real customer on RepairClinic

That quote highlights something critical: thermostats often get blamed when the real issue is elsewhere in the circuit. Spending $45 on an OEM thermostat won't fix a bad breaker. Start with the affordable aftermarket part, and if it doesn't solve the problem, you know to look deeper into the electrical system.

Installation Reality Check

Both OEM and aftermarket versions install exactly the same way. You'll need a 1/4" nutdriver and a Phillips screwdriver. The job takes 30–60 minutes even if you've never done it before.

The thermostat mounts to the blower housing with two screws. Two wire terminals push on—no soldering, no special tools. If you can change a light fixture, you can change this thermostat.

Here's what matters: the mounting holes and terminal spacing are standardized. The aftermarket part bolts up in exactly the same location as OEM. There's no grinding, no adapting, no "making it fit."

What About Compatibility?

This is where people get nervous. Will an aftermarket 3977767 really work in your specific dryer?

Yes. This thermostat is compatible with hundreds of Whirlpool, Kenmore, Maytag, and Roper dryer models. It replaces part numbers WP3977767, AP6009043, 3399693, and PS11742185. If your dryer originally came with any of those part numbers, the aftermarket version is a direct swap.

That includes models like:

  • Kenmore 110 series (11060012001, 11060172002, 11062602101)
  • Whirlpool 4KWED series (4KWED4605FW0, 4KWED4815FW0, 4KWED5700JW0)
  • Maytag and Roper equivalents using the same platform

Cross-reference your model number before ordering—but if it's on the compatibility list, you're good with aftermarket.

Our Verdict

Buy the aftermarket 3977767 thermostat unless you have a specific warranty or contractual reason to choose OEM. You'll save $35–40, get the same 1-year warranty, and complete your repair 2–3 days faster. This isn't a complex component where OEM engineering matters—it's a thermal switch that either works or doesn't. Aftermarket works.

Frequently Asked Questions

Will aftermarket thermostats last as long as OEM?

In real-world use, yes. High limit thermostats fail due to thermal cycling and age, not brand names. Both OEM and aftermarket thermostats use bimetallic disc technology rated for the same temperature range. Expect 5–10 years of service from either option under normal use.

Can using an aftermarket part void my dryer warranty?

Only if your dryer is still under the original manufacturer warranty. Once that expires, you can use whatever parts you want without voiding anything. If you're still covered, check your warranty terms—some allow aftermarket parts, some don't.

What if the aftermarket thermostat doesn't fix my no-heat problem?

Then the thermostat wasn't your problem. Common culprits beyond the high limit thermostat include the heating element itself, the thermal fuse, the cycling thermostat, and—as one customer discovered—a bad 240V breaker. Test continuity on all thermal components before ordering parts. If you're getting 240V to the dryer and the heating element tests good, only then replace thermostats.

Ready to go aftermarket?

3977767 · Factory direct · 1-year warranty

Shop 3977767 →